Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
P.L. Stuart

Book Review We Men Ash and Shadow by HL Tinsley

Recommended Posts

Book review of WE MEN OF ASH AND SHADOW by @Holly Tinsley


When the three most important components of a book for me (and most readers) – being plot, characters, prose – are all so good you can’t decide which one is the best component, it’s a wondrous thing. That is where I found myself after reading the outstanding Holly Tinsley’s debut Grimdark novel, “We Men of Ash and Shadow”, Book 1 in the “Vanguard Chronicles”. This book is simply stellar on all three of those aspects I noted, and a fantastic read.

I wanted to address, up front, the minor issue that I had with the book, which in no way robbed me of the overall pleasure of my reading. I appreciate any perspective from which a book is written. I enjoy first person, third person, multiple POVs, etc. It does not matter what tense, etc. the book is written is, as long as it’s a good book. That said, Tinsley does switch POVs frequently, that may seem slightly abrupt at first, but I did quickly grow accustomed to it, and even enjoyed it by the end of the novel. Again, aforementioned is a quibble, not a showstopper by any means. This book is far too brilliantly-done for the POV shift issue to make it any less than a five-star novel for me.

Let’s start with that beautiful, haunting, descriptive prose. It’s elegant, sometimes brutal, and I found it quite original and refreshing. Tinsley has an uncanny knack of hitting tone and mood perfectly. She knows what to write, and when to write it. There is a brooding, melancholy, and creepy vibe to the whole book, infused with poignant hope and optimism, redemption, and catharsis. Tinsley is a master of tension, and she knows just how to build the suspense and angst leading to a blood-pressure raising scene. The dialogue is witty, ironic, tight and sharp. Tinsley says so much, with so little, when it comes to her character’s speaking parts in the book. Despite the brevity there, some of the lines delivered are just plain hilarious, some depressing, some optimistic, and some manage to evoke multiple emotions at once. The comedy versus tragedy in the book is so well-balanced - teetering on the point of a knife - by Tinsley, and it works splendidly.

The setting, for me, immediately brought to mind images of a 19th century Jack-the-Ripper-esque style gas-lamp London, or Paris (considering the French-styled names that permeate the book). D’Orsee, the city in which the action takes place, is divided along class lines. Different zones demark different levels of wealth and affluence. The bulk of the narrative, however, takes place in the undesirable zones. On the whole, D’Orsee is a very grim, and sinister place. Organized criminals, under the guise of legitimacy, run the city. The senior thugs have imposed a military-style occupation of the place. Crime is only permitted when sanctioned by the mob bosses. But criminality is rampant. Prostitution, petty theft, and even murder, are the least heinous crimes committed, to tell you something about how bleak things are in D’Orsee. It’s place where corruption flourishes, revolt against the system is always around the corner, and the whole city feels like a tinder-box, ready to explode at any moment. That’s because it is, and there is a history of bloody rebellion that hangs over the city like a death sentence.

Be warned, there is a fair dose of violence in the novel. I did love the heart-pounding fight scenes, which were very well written. There is lots of trauma, both physical and psychological, that occurs, but it is not about gore-splattered pages this book. It’s more about the innuendo and creepiness I spoke of that seeps through the paragraphs, and a sense of sadness regarding the human condition and the terrible things we are capable of. There are lots of damaged, morally grey people in “We Men of Ash and Shadow”, and they fit right into a grey, depressing, backdrop that is D’Orsee.

The protagonist of the book is the eponymous John Vanguard of the series. He’s become a legend due to previous military service, and his current role as a sort of paid vigilante (really a mercenary). Vanguard's role is to rid the streets of D’Orsee of those who are considered so abominable and unredeemable that their deaths are deemed a service to the citizens. But Vanguard harbours secrets and a complicated past. Vanguard is an incredible character. I believe he will ultimately go down as one of Grimdark fiction’s great protagonists, right up there with Jorg Ancarth and Sand an Glokta. He’s burnt-out, disgruntled, a shell of what he was. He’s a killer, tortured by what he has seen and done, and employed by a tyrannical mob figure whom he despises. But underneath the grime is a man of integrity, with a great heart.

The story is very much about the unforgettable Vanguard, and his personal arch. That said, the secondary and tertiary characters are also highly memorable. Tarryn, Kosic, Sanquain, Mandego, Sanderson, Henriette, and so many more will have you invested in both their individual stories, and how they impact that of Vanguard’s.

The world Tinsley has crafted is wonderfully gritty, and completely authentic. Tinsley doesn’t pull any punches on how menacing and dreadful life is in D’Orsee, and trust me, you won’t want her to. The worldbuilding is top notch. Tinsley gives the reader enough tantalizing back-story and detail about some of the events that led to how things deteriorating so badly in D’Orsee, that you will be completely immersed.

To call this novel a page-turner would not be giving it it’s due. It is a smooth, easy, addictive read, like aged rum. You will loose yourself in the book, and forget about what time it is. What a smashing debut by Tinsley - kudos! She is assuredly destined for Grimdark royalty, and can’t wait for installment #2 as Tinsley continues to accumulate jewels to add to her tiara!


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

To @Holly Tinsley, our Dads, Gunnar and preserving beauty,
Holly Tinsley's excellent We Men of Ash and Shadow.Wow, what a dedication, I've never been so emotional before even starting a book. I, too, was very fortunate to have been raised by a loving and supportive father. Mine is sorely missed. The intriguing character names continue to bounce around my skull. Tarryn Leersac is my favorite, very evocative. Phonetically Tearin' (or split). People leer at his prettiness, but sometimes can't see him, like being mistaken for his dead father by his own mother, Lady Leersac, whom will get leered and ridiculed for being now an empty sack of a Lady, while she'll leer longingly for attention after losing her husband, money, friends, priviledge and mind. Henriette envisions a sophisticated parental madam, but the name is just a role she plays. Carmen, a libretto was written by Henri Meilhac and Ludovic Halévy, a depiction of proletarian life, immorality, and lawlessness where Carmen is a gypsy who seduces a soldier, interesting. Vanguard, hardly cutting edge, is shamed, stuck and burned by his past, just ash, or is he? The book title is apt, We Men of Ash and Shadow because we are just wee men of ash and shadow. Different pockets of D' Orsee are under the shadow of, occluded by, singular strongmen, a walled city and foundries belching ash. The book's name, as that of the characters, is nuanced, not anvilicious. The reader is not beat over the head, though characters in this grimdark gaslamp world are. Holly Tinsley wrItes effortlessly well, not showing off. The story builds steadily, is not forced, with natural shifts. Characters are layered, through accretion, skillfully. Holly is generous, an impressive author. This is but the start, The Hand That Casts The Bone (Vanguard #2) will, I'm confident, be even better than this SPFBO finalist, continuing to flesh out the characters, literally and figuratively. Can't wait.




Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Holly Tinsley said:

'The reader is not beat over the head, though characters in this grimdark gaslamp world are.' - this might be my favourite line in a review ever haha.

Thanks for such kind words, particularly about the dedication. Making me a bit emotional over here...

Thank you for the kind words, @Holly Tinsley. I'm fairly pleased with the write-up, it came together pretty well, somewhat satisfying, especially given your positive reaction, for like with a cook, the biggest critic of any dish will always be the chef themself. Of course, like in a kitchen or fireplace, top-notch ingredients simply make a presentation a whole lot easier to assemble. I could re-write my short review a hundred times and it would never feel complete. When do you decide to put a manuscript down, say enough already, this is the 'final' version? I read @P.L. Stuart excellent review after I posted mine and was struck by two things, first and foremost, his takes the "Lord and King" crown and just how different the two ''criticisms' of the same superb novel are. That's one of the reasons (aside for the obvious that in a month he'll have three very well- received books published, and, I, well, will have none) the writer's battle, which you kindly judge and offer discreet feedback, is so fun and interesting. Give people the same starting point, then enjoy and contrast the completely different destinations. Thanks, Holly and PL, but enough of the love fest, this is grimdark, where's my candlestick?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Create New...